The Ultimate Guide to San Antonio’s Pizza Scene: 27 Must-Try Pizzerias

San Antonio may be known for its tacos and Tex-Mex, but its pizza scene is equally impressive. Whether you’re craving a classic New York slice, deep-dish indulgence, or an artisan Neapolitan-style pie, this city has something for every pizza lover. We’ve rounded up 27 of San Antonio’s must-try pizzerias, sorted by category, so you can find the perfect pie no matter your craving.

Local Legends: San Antonio’s Classic Pizzerias

These legendary pizza spots have been serving up slices for years and have built a loyal following.

Barbaro – 2720 McCullough Ave.

A staple for pizza lovers, Barbaro offers daily happy hour deals from 4-6 p.m. with a menu featuring gourmet toppings and handcrafted crusts. Order online or reserve a table for a perfect night out.

Big Lou’s – 2048 S. WW White Rd.

Home of the famous 42-inch pizza, Big Lou’s is a must-visit for anyone who loves oversized portions and great flavors. They also offer wings, pasta, and salads for a well-rounded meal.

Goomba’s Pizzeria – Multiple locations

For a nostalgic treat, start with their delicious pizza rolls, then dig into the fan-favorite Goombas Supreme pizza.

Little Italy Restaurant & Pizzeria – 824 Afterglow St.

Owned by the Visocaro family from Sicily, Little Italy serves authentic Italian and New York-style pizzas alongside a full deli for fresh-cut meats and cheeses.

Lovers Pizzeria – 105 E. Ashby Pl.

A hidden gem in San Antonio, this small but mighty pizza joint frequently sells out, so be sure to get there early for the freshest pies.

Fancier Fare: Elevated Pizza & Wine Pairings

For those looking for a more refined pizza experience, these upscale pizzerias deliver quality ingredients and elegant settings.

Braza Brava Pizzeria Napoletana – 7959 Broadway St. #300

Enjoy a sophisticated night out with half-off bottles of wine every Monday and Tuesday when you order a pizza.

Dough Pizzeria Napoletana – Multiple locations

A perfect date night spot, Dough Pizzeria’s Margherita pizza and house-made burrata are must-tries.

Flume Pizzeria – 200 S. Alamo St.

Located along the River Walk, Flume blends Texas flavors with traditional Neapolitan pizza, creating what they call Texapoletana.

Fralo’s – 23651 W. I-10

Enjoy a family recipe that has been perfected over the years, with live music on select nights to enhance the experience.

Volare Italian Restaurant and Pizzeria – 3902 McCullough Ave.

Offering event catering and a cozy atmosphere, Volare’s caprese pizza is a fan favorite.

Online Ordering: Pizza at Your Fingertips

These pizzerias make it easy to enjoy a fresh, delicious pizza at home.

Il Forno – 122 Nogalitos St.

Ranked #24 on the 2023 50 Top Pizza list in the U.S., Il Forno uses house-made meats, sauces, and dough, and sources local produce and wines.

Fife & Farro – 221 Newell Ave.

Located in Pullman Market, this spot offers pizza-making classes every Monday and Tuesday for hands-on fun.

Julian’s Italian Kitchen and Pizzeria – Multiple locations

A family-owned business for three generations, Julian’s also offers a bulk menu for hosting events.

Trilogy Pizza – 19141 Stone Oak Parkway #113

Deep-dish lovers will find heaven here, plus rewards members get $20 off every five online orders.

Mad Pecker Brewing Co. – 6025 Tezel Rd.

A brewery with pizza, wings, and great craft beers – what more could you ask for?

Rome’s Pizza – Multiple locations

Since 1986, Rome’s has been serving gourmet handcrafted pizzas with creative toppings.

Pizza Papi – 2842 Goliad Rd.

Don’t be fooled by the food truck appearance – their Meat Luvr pizza is a crowd favorite.

Sofia’s Pizzeria – Multiple locations

A family-run pizzeria with three locations, perfect for takeout or catering.

Gluten-Free & Specialty Crusts

For those avoiding gluten, these pizzerias offer delicious alternatives.

Julian’s Italian Pizzeria & Kitchen – Multiple locations

Offers gluten-free pizzas alongside oven-baked pasta dishes.

Lou’s Woodfire Pizza – 11930 US-90 Suite #101

Try their cauliflower crust for a healthier take on wood-fired pizza.

Mellow Mushroom – 115 N. Loop 1604 E., #2100

Known for its gluten-free pies, veggie options, and mocktails.

Pizzeria Vesuvio – 1110 S. Alamo St.

Try the King William Pizza, a double-crusted stuffed pizza with seasoned mozzarella, bacon, and pepperoni.

It’s Delivery! Pizza Right to Your Door

For those nights when you just want to stay in, these pizzerias have you covered.

Guillermo’s – 618 McCullough Ave.

Delivers with 24-hour advance notice, with immediate service available for an extra fee.

Maar’s Pizza & More – 14218 Nacogdoches Rd.

The Jalapeno-Cheddar Meteor Bites are a spicy, cheesy delight.

Pizza Patron – Multiple locations

Serving San Antonio for over 20 years, check out the Los Otros mural at the Medical Center location.

Poppy’s Pizza – 7115 Blanco Rd. Suite 107

A family-run pizzeria serving NY-style pies and wings, with 10% off for active service members.

Royal Pizza – 4415 De Zavala Rd.

A classic Italian-style pizzeria, known for Spinach & Ricotta pizza and delicious Stromboli.

Final Slice: The Best Pizza in San Antonio

San Antonio’s pizza scene is as diverse as the city itself, offering something for every kind of pizza lover. Whether you’re looking for classic New York slices, deep-dish indulgence, wood-fired Neapolitan, or gluten-free alternatives, the Alamo City delivers.

Did we miss your favorite pizza spot? Let us know your go-to pizza place in San Antonio! 🍕

Kristen Smith, Realtor best realtor in San Antonio